SPfreaks Forum

 

forum

SPfreaks Forums

Welcome to a place to share thoughts and questions with other SPfreaks. Browse a forum below or start a new thread in a forum

Forum: General

Topic: Rate Songs For A Sailor

This topic contains 16 replies, has 1,839 voices, and was last updated by Profile photo of anonymous Anonymous 7 years ago.

On confuciousconfusing wrote:

I know this has been posted over at the official forum, however id like to know what the freaks here would rate it.

This is mine.

Song For A Song – 9/10
Widow Wake My Mind – 5/10
Stitch In Time – 1/10
Astral Planes – 7/10

In loving memory of Bimbolin.
Profile photo of Danni
Participant
On Danni wrote:

At first, really disappointed. Then more optimistic, thank god.

Song For A Song – 3/10
Widow Wake My Mind – 2/10
Stitch In Time – 7/10
Astral Planes – 8/10

Profile photo of Daysofthephoenix
Member
On Daysofthephoenix wrote:

Song For A Song – 7/10
Widow Wake My Mind – 4/10
Stitch In Time – 8/10
Astral Planes – 5/10

There’s mine.

Give me the disk, Angela.Somewhere in the world, Dongsoo Kim loves you...Thirsting for God in a Land of Shallow Wells.365 Days of Winter!!!
Profile photo of mr.benway
Participant
On mr.benway wrote:

Song For A Song – 6/10
Widow Wake My Mind – 2/10
Stitch In Time – 4/10
Astral Planes – 5/10

Profile photo of anonymous
Member
On Anonymous wrote:

Song For A Song – 6/10
Widow Wake My Mind – 3/10
Stitch In Time – 7/10
Astral Planes – 8/10.

Profile photo of salkema
Member
On salkema wrote:

SFAS: 9/10
WWMM: 7/10
SIT: 9/10
AP: 6/10

Pretty good EP in my opinion. Stitch and SFAS are awesome.

Profile photo of some pumpkins
Participant
On some pumpkins wrote:

song for a son: 7
widow wake my mind: 7
stitch: 9
astral planes: 9

what's wrong with you is good for what's wrong with me
Profile photo of amnesia
Member
On amnesia wrote:

Seems like im the only one who hates Stitch, i should be ashamed of myself :lol:

In loving memory of Bimbolin.
Profile photo of Sven
Participant
On Sven wrote:

Song For A Song – 5/10
Widow Wake My Mind – 2/10
Stitch In Time – 3/10
Astral Planes – 3/10

Profile photo of pumpkinfan
Member
On pumpkinfan wrote:

SFAS 6/10
WWMM 7/10
Stitch 6/10
Astral 1/10

The lyrics in Astral are non-existent. Major disappointment to me, given the other aspects of the song.

Profile photo of Daysofthephoenix
Member
On Daysofthephoenix wrote:

Well the lyrics in Astral planes are non existent but the lyrics in Widow Wake My Mind are just as annoying but you rated that higher.

The lyrics aren’t any better in that song with all the constant oh’s I have to suffer through.
I guess the music is better though than Astral planes, that song just makes me cringe. :(

Give me the disk, Angela.Somewhere in the world, Dongsoo Kim loves you...Thirsting for God in a Land of Shallow Wells.365 Days of Winter!!!
Profile photo of mirrorboxer
Member
On mirrorboxer wrote:

Song For A Song – Better
Widow Wake My Mind – Growing on Me
Stitch In Time – Best
Astral Planes – Good

I don’t want to compare them to past work so I am only comparing the new songs to themselves.

Profile photo of Arthur
Moderator
On Arthur wrote:

I don’t want to compare them to past work so I am only comparing the new songs to themselves.[/quote:gtoca8my]
That’s what everybody should do, I guess. :)

My figures are mentioned somewhere else on this forum already, i don’t recall them anymore… But in general I was quite happy with the recent material, except for Widow. That song doesn’t grow on me, I’m afraid. Well, whatever, still 3 more to enjoy.

Edit: found it back.

Song For A Son: 9/10 (the guitar solo really does it for me!)
Widow Wake My Mind: 6/10
A Stitch In Time: 7.5/10
Astral Planes: 7/10 (I liked the live version a bit more)

Billy Corgan, December 2, 2008 : "Not everyone understands our death trip. But you do. And that's what matters."
Profile photo of mirrorboxer
Member
On mirrorboxer wrote:

Realistically if someone is going to give Glass & the Ghost Children and Thru the Eyes of Ruby a 10/10 and then give songs like Cherub Rock and Tonight Tonight a 9/10, do any of the new songs break past 5/10……doubtful. That being said, the new songs aren’t bad, just not realy comparable. And I think that is a fair assesment.

Profile photo of last_rose_of_summer
Member
On last_rose_of_summer wrote:

Song For A Son – 7/10
Widow Wake My Mind – 6/10
Stitch In Time – 8/10
Astral Planes – 5/10

Profile photo of Voidhanger
Participant
On Voidhanger wrote:

I’m hesitant to assign ratings to these, especially since I’m still letting this release sink in, but I definitely think \"A Stitch in Time\" is one of the best songs they’ve released in the recent past and even ranks pretty highly in their entire discography for me.

I’d probably rate \"Astral Planes\" lowest of the four, the lyrics are kind of annoying, and the other two songs hover in the middle somewhere as solid songs.

Profile photo of anonymous
Member
On Anonymous wrote:

nice to see a few like Astral Planes 8)
I can’t rate them…I enjoy each of them in their own respected ways…there are parts in WWMM that I really like the breakdown, Astral Planes is just Epic to me…SFAS nice and classic sounding, Stitch in Time is like being in another country-which makes me like it even more-it just doesn’t have a typical sound.
Over all I think TbK EP 1 is damn good!
Matter of fact I must go and listen again for the 50th+ time now since getting the actual EP :D

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

×
 
 
×
 
  • Strength indicator
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Already a member? Sign In

×